Wai 3553
The Waitangi Tribunal's urgent inquiry into the curriculum reform led by Erica Stanford
What follows are select quotations from the Stage 2 reports, with commentary from me, originally posted on Facebook.
What follows are select quotations from the Stage 2 reports, with commentary from me, originally posted on Facebook.
"a meeting was held on 12 March 2024 between the Curriculum MAG and Minister Stanford, the Secretary of Education, Ms MacGregor-Reid, Dr Pollock, and Minister Stanford’s political adviser. We do not know the exact nature of the ‘concerns’ that were escalated to Ms MacGregor-Reid, except that they likely related to the Curriculum MAG’s perception of its scope. Ahead of the meeting, a draft of the Curriculum MAG’s report was sent to Minister Stanford’s office. At that meeting, the Crown informed us, Minister Stanford ‘made clear her expectation’ the Ministry of Education would ‘immediately’ begin preparation for the revision of the English and Mathematics learning areas in accordance with the Curriculum MAG’s recommendations ‘so that this process could begin promptly’ after the Minister had formally considered its report." (page 88)
The first thing to be clear about is what advisory groups are for and what public service guidelines say they are permitted to do.
They are a useful mechanism for Ministers to access advice from outside their department.
However, their role is to only give advice. They lack the statutory authority to do anything else, like write a curriculum.
But that is exactly what this MAG did, almost from the outset. Within days of their first meeting they were writing. They found the UK curriculum especially useful as a reference point.
No "need to reinvent the wheel!" Melissa Derby says.
All that needs to be done is to "take the best of what others have done and fit it to our needs". Elizabeth Rata agrees.
So much for the refresh work done up to 2023 – it's ditched in an instant, the eyes of 12 cast ashore, certain that's where the 'best' is.
No evaluation or analysis of their reference materials. No sense of maybe. No acknowledgement of complexity. And so they get to work, and "write the documents". Documents the Minister instructs the Ministry to use, along with the report they provide, to guide the curriculum reform process. That work is both out of scope and in violation of public service guidelines. But they push on, apparently with Ministerial assent.
This is a failure of good government. It is the pure expression of executive power, used to force through what a small group think our education system should be like.
What did the refresh work done by a huge number of sector experts over a number of years get so wrong?
Why was this small group the only ones in the country who could put it right?
⚫
"The Crown in its closing submissions stated the Ministry of Education was aware of criticisms of a knowledge-rich approach and that the wider curriculum principles were designed to mitigate them. However, we have not been provided with any official advice analysing such risks. Furthermore, the reports cited by the Crown in support of its knowledge-rich approach do not adequately canvas the risks and largely present a one-sided narrative of the benefits. A number of critiques, however, exist regarding the knowledge-rich approach, including its implications for the transmission of indigenous knowledge" (page 131)
Does knowledge matter? Of course it does.
Should schools be places where children gain knowledge? Of course.
No one is disputing this.
But, knowledge in and of itself is not neutral or 'good' or harmless. A curriculum cannot be stuffed full of knowledge and automatically deemed to be good for children.
What struck me during the Tribunal inquiry was the sense the Ministry seemed to have that the selection of knowledge for the curriculum was a mere procedural, rational, almost apolitical process. All they were doing was applying design principles. Like magic, the right knowledge would appear for selection.
What naive nonsense.
Look at what has time and time again been left out, or distorted, or sequenced in odd ways in the curriculum drafts.
Look at what has been included and given prominence.
Deciding what knowledge is in and what out of a curriculum is one of the most political things we can do.
Kids can get harmed by these decisions.
The Tribunal found the Crown had breached the principle of protection.
Its curriculum design principles meant their decisions lowered the emphasis on te reo, tikanga, and mātauranga Māori and teachers’ capacity to meaningfully incorporate content from te ao Māori given "the volume of prescribed content and mandatory teaching times for reading, writing, and mathematics."
Knowledge, crowding out other knowledge.
⚫
"... the Crown argued a knowledge-rich approach would contribute to enhancing equitable outcomes in Aotearoa New Zealand. In developing this approach, the Ministry of Education contracted Learning First to provide a literature review about knowledge-rich curricula. However, the Australian company provided no criticism of the knowledge-rich approach, an arguable reflection of the brief provided in its agreement with the Ministry, and linked inequity primarily with socio-economic inequality, without any reference to Māori-specific research". (page 137)
For clarity: the Ministry wanted evidence this approach would work. So they contracted a firm – Learning First – to write a report justifying it. Then they relied on that report to justify the reforms.
And there is important context here. The Ministry ignored its own evidence about equity, such as the Huia Kaimanawa report.
Our children deserve an education system built on a robust process. Erica Stanford has built one based on the reckons of her mates.
⚫
"Professor Rata’s publications are referenced in the material that the Ministry of Education relied on when developing the knowledge-rich approach. For example, the Tim Surma et al article, the Learning First literature review, and the 2025 review of the English national curriculum, as well as the Australian Education Research Organisation report. In our view, this circular loop of information has the effect of reinforcing the validity of Minister Stanford’s predetermined position. In fact, there are 15 references to Professor Rata’s publications in the Australian Education Research Organisation report alone." (page 140)
The Australian Education Research Organisation (AERO) report references Rata 15 times!!!!! That's the same Rata who was on the Curriculum MAG and led the writing team that produced the first draft of the senior English curriculum.
A process that has a "circular loop of information" is not a robust process.
The independent workplace review into the curriculum centre found much the same thing: Ministry employees expressed concern that free and frank advice was not being given by senior leaders “out of a desire to follow the advice of the Minister”.
Claims of this curriculum being evidence-based are very shaky, and getting more shaky the more we learn.
IMPORTANT CONTEXT
In mid 2025 an independent performance evaluation was commissioned by Australia's Federal Education Minister into AERO. It has been withheld.
AERO themselves have objected to its release, saying it would
Undermine trust in the quality of evidence AERO generates, causing educators to stop using its resources
Reduce participation in research studies and inhibit candid stakeholder engagement
Cause serious reputational harm to AERO
Damage AERO’s relationships with partner organisations
⚫
"The existence of research about Māori inequity is not disputed. What is questioned is the absence of analysis about Māori inequity in relation to knowledge rich in relevant documents. For example, there are clear contradictions between the results from the Huia Kaimanawa study and the emphasis on specificity of content in the knowledge-rich approach. However, we did not see an analysis of these contradictions in any of the Ministry’s advice to Minister Stanford." (page 140)
There are multiple breaches of Te Tiriti evident in this one quote.
partnership, due to the lack of meaningful engagement with Māori research
protection, due to the decision to favour a knowledge-rich approach over other others known to support Māori success
equity, due to the disregard of Māori voices
government, due to the failure to make any robust assessment of the contradictions and provide advice regarding them.
This is why the curriculum reform process undertaken by Stanford is bigger than an education dispute. It is a democratic one, one that asks us all to think about where a government in Aotearoa New Zealand gets their power from, and whether those powers be limited in any way.
In our specific context, this takes on a constitutional hue given the weakness of our government system and the dominance of the executive. This government has acted in a way that suggests the power of the executive is absolute. All that is required is election victory and then it may do as it wishes. This is a very simple and naive understanding of democracy. It is also a very dangerous one. For a government to act in the interests of the people it governs, there must also exist guidelines, systems, rules, and institutions that act as a constraint on that power.
Without those constraints, and them being respected or protected, we have a government that acts as if it is infallible, that can act as it pleases, including disregarding the voices of those it has decided it can speak and make decisions for. Ultimately, and ironically, the failure to recognise these constraints rob a curriculum development process of the very things it needs if it is to become something that will help all children.
⚫
"although the Crown contended it was aware of criticisms of knowledge-rich, we have not been provided with any official advice analysing such criticisms. The Crown’s claim that a knowledge-rich approach would support more equitable education outcomes for Māori students was also not substantiated with relevant research. Moreover, the Crown’s approach appears to have disregarded relevant evidence regarding Māori achievement in Māori-medium and kaupapa Māori settings and the findings of the Huia Kaimanawa study. Instead, we noted the Ministry of Education’s reliance on reports produced by proponents of a knowledge-rich approach, which presented a largely one-sided view of knowledge-rich and served to reinforce the Minister’s predetermined position. In our view, this lacked the kind of robust scrutiny we would expect during curriculum development and in official advice to the Minister." (page 144)
⚫
"What is of interest to us is whether the interests of ākonga Māori were considered adequately by the Minister and her officials. What we can see is that the Crown hitched itself to the concept of knowledge rich without any serious discussion of whether it would produce more equitable education outcomes for Māori. There was simply an acceptance of the theory of it improving equity without any apparent analysis of its applicability to the Aotearoa New Zealand context. Officials seemingly furnished the Minister with information that backed her ideological position, such as the Australian Education Research Organisation report and the Learning First literature review. As far as we are aware, there was no questioning of this material, or any serious consideration of critiques of it." (page 144)
It is such a basic, common sense principle being violated here: if you're seeking to solve a problem, your best shot comes from looking at all your options. That the curriculum reform process led by Stanford has not raises significant questions about its claims to being a robust, evidence-informed one. These concerns are compounded by the secrecy surrounding its development, including the active but undocumented involvement of the Minister's office, the absence of critique of the approach in the Learning First literature review, and the major questions now being asked about the credibility of the Australian Education Research Organisation in Australia.
Our kids deserve better. Teachers deserve better.
⚫
"our view is that the change in emphasis on the treaty alongside the adoption of a knowledge-rich approach marked a break from the former curriculum reform process. Although feedback received during earlier engagement on the refresh would still have been valuable to the Crown, it was not a substitute for genuine engagement during the design and development of the knowledge-rich curriculum. This view was shared by Heidi Hayward, principal of Dunedin North Intermediate and Vice President of New Zealand Principals’ Federation, who emphasised that the collaborative work with the sector ‘took place prior to the switch to a knowledge-rich curriculum’ and that ‘[t]he sector has largely been locked out since this change in direction’. As noted section 4.2.2.3., the Minister’s knowledge-rich approach was also untested in Aotearoa New Zealand, and there was no ākonga Māori-specific research supporting it. In our view, these factors meant genuine engagement was critical." (page 149)
The Crown claimed the following (contradictory) positions during the inquiry:
The refresh work done required a significant change of direction.
The feedback gained during the highly consultative and inclusive refresh work meant the requirement to consult was reduced during the shift to a knowledge-rich curriculum.
There is a special kind of duplicitous elision happening here.
The refresh process up to 2023 had multiple sector voices included in the design process.
Those voices have been locked out of the design process since then, reduced to occasional moments where they get asked how much they like what's being made without their input.
The difference is vast.
⚫
"Another area of concern raised by claimant and interested party witnesses was the absence of expert involvement in the curriculum development. As noted in section 3.2.2.4, Professor Hunter stated that nobody she knew in mathematics education research had been involved in the development of the Mathematics and Statistics learning area. This compared to former Governments which, in her experience, had brought together consultancy groups with expertise in mathematics education to give feedback and share ideas. This type of engagement, she said, had been ‘completely eliminated’." (page 156)
Professor Jodie Hunter is an internationally respected academic who has recently been appointed President of the Mathematics Education Research Group of Australasia. The fact she knows no-one involved in the development of the mathematics curriculum should horrify every parent in this country.
But what is of even greater concern is that this is reflective of the thin evidence base that has been apparent from the outset of the reforms. For instance, the report of the Curriculum MAG contains 35 references in total, 5 of which are from the MAG members themselves.
⚫
"In sum, while the treaty is still present in the 2025 framework, its relevance is no longer explicitly connected to the Crown’s broader treaty obligations in the context of education, such as the active protection of taonga Māori. Moreover, while references to mātauranga Māori remain, the former emphasis on schools working with tangata whenua to incorporate local content from te ao Māori is expressed permissively (‘may choose’) rather than as an integral process to ensure curriculum integrity. This is a far cry from the 2023 framework, which asked school leaders to hold themselves accountable to the treaty and their communities as they set and reviewed their school curriculum. On balance, we consider the treaty is no longer at the heart of the framework." (page 175)
Local content is knowledge.
Given these reforms have now made that optional, what is it about that knowledge that makes it not suitable for a knowledge-rich curriculum?
Because, remember, the Ministry has been applying clear design principles to help them make the selections about what knowledge qualifies for the knowledge-rich curriculum, and also what doesn't.
Those design principles have resulted in them deciding that local content is an option.
Those decisions are saying: Māori are not central and te ao Māori is not essential.
This is a political decision. It reflects a specific set of values and ideas about this place and what education here is for.
⚫
"We share claimant and interested party witness concerns that prominent subject-matter experts, including Māori, appear to have been sidelined or not meaningfully included in the development of the draft learning areas. In our view, their involvement also relates to curriculum integrity and ensuring the draft produced for consultation best suits the needs of ākonga Māori and the Aotearoa New Zealand context. While the Crown said Māori historians were involved in drafting content, it has not disclosed who they were so as to provide confidence to Māori and the sector." (page 179)
Secrecy, combined with a closed, select group, is no way to develop a robust curriculum that meets the needs of all learners.
It makes it vulnerable to ideological capture.
It makes it prone to making some knowledge, perspectives and people invisible.
That is exactly what has happened with Stanford's curriculum reforms. It is very apparent in the ANZ Histories curriculum, where the act of rebalancing it is nothing more than cover for the reassertion of a colonising narrative.
When no genuine effort is made to partner, things become unseen and there can be no protection. All that is secured are the prejudices and assumptions of the powerful.
⚫
"Ms Hayward, for example, stated the drafts were ‘fundamentally flawed due to a lack of transparent, genuine co-design with the education professionals who best understand our learners’. She noted a number of issues with the curriculum content, including the shift to a year-by-year curriculum when many classrooms are composite in nature (teaching multiple years groups at once) and asked how ‘such a significant change’ could ‘have come about without discussion or engagement with the sector and without consideration of something as fundamental as the staffing ramifications ?’. She explained that in the rural school she previously led, this shift would have required her to teach eight curricula simultaneously to the different year groups." (page 184)
This flaw has still not been addressed.
It exposes a deeper, fundamental flaw in the reforms led by Stanford: the idea that you can design a curriculum without including those who are the experts in what curriculum delivery looks like, day after day in wildly different contexts.
⚫
"Noticeably, iwi and hapu perspectives on the Aotearoa New Zealand’s histories curriculum and relationship building with schools were absent from the Education Review Office’s report. As Associate Professors Manning and Mahuika observed, ‘[o]nly one kaumatua was interviewed’ and no iwi or hapu historians or Māori academic experts were interviewed. Without these perspectives, the Education Review Office – and, by implication, the Ministry of Education and Minister Stanford – would not have had clear information about the experience of iwi and hapu, whether positive or negative, regarding the Aotearoa New Zealand’s histories curriculum." (page 193)
That report was used to justify the 'rebalancing' of the history curriculum. Just so we're clear, rebalancing is the polite word for the reassertion of a colonial narrative.
One would expect such a significant decision to be based on a robust case for change and include the voices of those impacted by the proposed change.
That is, after all, how good government is meant to operate in a democracy.
But, as is becoming clearer with Stanford's reforms, the job of evidence is to fit pre-determined positions.
No one is safe, no one is protected, no one has their interests secured when government operates in this way. And that is why the Tribunal found one of the breaches to be a breach of good government.
⚫
"another factor that neither the Ministry of Education nor Minister Stanford appeared to consider was the potential impact that ‘rebalancing’ the curriculum might have on ākonga Māori. According to Associate Professors Manning and Mahuika, the Ministry and Minister Stanford seemed to have overlooked findings in the Education Review Office’s report that ‘indicated there was also much to celebrate’, including teachers’ enjoyment in teaching the content and that Māori and Pasifika students, especially, were enjoying learning it." (page 195)
When I read things like this I can't help but think of Elizabeth Rata declaring her intent to use curriculum to end decolonisation's success.
Combine that with the fact that rebalancing is code for the reassertion of the colonial narrative, and what we have is a curriculum that shows a callous disregard for the needs and interests of Māori and Pasifika students.
Honestly, I do not know how this new History curriculum can be taught ethically.
⚫
"The Education Review Office ‘heard that the increased focus on Māori histories’ had encouraged the participation of Māori students and school leaders reported that ‘the value placed on Māori knowledge lifts Māori students’ sense of identity, self-esteem, and mana’. Māori teachers similarly were enjoying teaching the Aotearoa New Zealand’s histories curriculum more than non Māori teachers. They also told the Education Review Office ‘the big ideas reflect[ed] their experiences and understanding, which is validating’ and that the curriculum had provided ‘opportunities for them to share their knowledge and culture with other staff, and students’. Despite these positive signs, the potential impact of changes to the Aotearoa New Zealand’s histories curriculum on ākonga Māori and kaiako Māori does not appear to have been considered by the Ministry of Education or Minister Stanford." (page 195)
Yesterday we heard that the Ministry's own internal advice was that up to 19,000 more students will fail the proposed NCEA replacement.
Māori are one of the groups of students disproportionately represented.
There are many unconcerned by this, including the Minister. It's just a work harder, learn better problem, they say.
That is not a credible view.
When a curriculum sidelines and invalidates the experiences, knowledge and culture of a student, the opportunities for them to find a way into the learning is much much harder. These knowledge-rich reforms do just that.
⚫
"Evidence in this inquiry showed the Minister is a supporter of the writings of American educationalist Professor Hirsch, who argues that teaching students the same core knowledge will promote equity by removing the advantage more privileged students have from their upbringing. Despite the lack of evidence that this would work here, the fact that Aotearoa New Zealand student achievement levels in mainstream schools have remained on a relative par with comparable countries, as well as recent data showing higher achievement rates of Māori students in kaupapa Māori schooling, officials very quickly began to reinforce the Minister’s predetermination on this course of action." (page 224)
Hirsch appeals to two kinds of people.
1) Those who don't actually know very much about education.
The idea seems appealing. Standardise what's learned, then when it comes to assessments you can create a level playing field.
Note that the privileged are not being asked to shift anything in Hirsch's model. Their knowledge is cemented at the centre and celebrated as the knowledge that is rich and worthy. It is those who are not privileged who must 'move' the most, who must leave behind what is theirs and go to the prize at the centre, where the privileged wait.
This is assimilationist educational theory.
This is exactly what our curriculum is now.
Whose knowledge is the crucial question. Māori being locked out of the curriculum development process is the essential fact.
2) Oppressors
See above.
That's why Hirsch is celebrated by far-right think tanks.
⚫
"In 2025, the Ministry went further in its embrace of knowledge-rich by commissioning a literature review on the subject from Australian education consultancy, Learning First (which, as we have set out, sought an affirmation of the benefits of knowledge rich). Like the Australian Education Research Organisation report, that review did not mention any criticism of knowledge rich and certainly made no mention of Māori or the treaty. Moreover, of the nearly 150 sources it cited, we detect only three as being from Aotearoa New Zealand, and two of those were from Professor Rata, a prominent adherent of knowledge rich and someone Minister Stanford had chosen as a member of her Curriculum MAG." (page 224)
Note what is guiding the curriculum work of the Ministry: an external organisation, working under contract.
Curriculum is secondary legislation. There should not be commercial imperatives influencing its development.
But this is exactly what has happened. Learning First had contractual terms to fulfil. They did. That work has directed the development of the curriculum.
The contractual terms did not seek a balanced view. They sought justification. Learning First were contracted because they position themselves as an organisation that specialises in the direction determined by the Minister.
That is not a robust process. It is a captured one.
⚫
“Officials presented the Australian Education Research Organisation report and the Learning First literature review as independent, objective pieces of work, but both organisations clearly had an agenda to promote knowledge rich … Ms Cleaver maintained that ‘evidence’ suggested that knowledge rich would be ‘more powerful in contributing to equitable outcomes’, but the ‘evidence’ she pointed to in making this claim was the Curriculum MAG’s advice to the Minister and the Australian Education Research Organisation report (which she described as ‘international evidence’). This was a self-reinforcing feedback loop.” (page 224)
When I read this, I struggle to see how a curriculum developed in such a manner can be a curriculum that supports all students.
Because note who Cleaver, and by extension the Ministry, are not pointing to in their evidence: NZCER, our universities and the researchers in them, Māori education bodies and experts, the Ministry’s own internal information and expertise.
What is described sounds a lot like groupthink to me.
That is what governance failure looks like.
⚫
“Despite the Minister’s focus on equity, the more than decade-long experience in England (reported in late 2025) is that knowledge rich has not improved equity between better off and disadvantaged students. Certainly, from the information provided in evidence, we did not see advice to the Minister about this report, raising concerns she was not provided with balanced and robust advice for consideration. It is also notable that officials did not promote a report the Ministry itself had commissioned on what equity in education looks like from a Māori perspective (the March 2024 Huia Kaimanawa report” (page 225)
When asked about the England experience at the Tribunal hearing, MacGregor-Reid acknowledged the findings but said, basically, that we were going to do it differently.
But how can one do it differently when one does not include perspectives and evidence that offer a view on how it might be different?
Not only did the Ministry not promote the Huia Kaimanawa report, at the Tribunal they feigned ignorance about it. Was it a deliberate oversight? I don't know. But what I find hard to square off is the professed desire to close the equity gap and the lack of consideration of research done here about how that might be achieved.
⚫
“We accept the utmost importance of equity in the design of the national curriculum, but we have a different perspective on it to the Minister and her officials. Given the existing inequities between Māori and other students, there is a heightened onus on the Crown to ensure that any changes it makes do not make those inequities worse. Knowledge rich is unproven in an Aotearoa New Zealand context, and it accordingly represents risk.” (page 225)
The problem with a knowledge-rich approach to curriculum is that it always centres the privileged. The burden is placed on those outside that circle to make the biggest leaps, while simultaneously learning that their culture and knowledge is peripheral.
Think about how that implicit message works, day after day, on a kid.
The only chance a knowledge-rich curriculum has to mitigate that problem is to ensure those voices are centred in the design phase. They haven’t been. They have been locked out, their rightful place taken by those who have a coloniser’s mindset: I know what is best for you.
⚫
“the Crown has not approached the reset of the curriculum with anything approaching the level of collaboration and co-design that characterised the previous curriculum refresh. The claimants readily described the engagement over the refresh as deliberate, thorough, and treaty compliant. In their eyes it was a model of partnership and set an expectation for future engagement. The limited opportunities for Māori input into the current reset have fallen well short of this standard.” (page 225)
Remember the refresh, that phase up to the middle of 2023 where genuine collaborative, inclusive, treaty-compliant design of curriculum happened? In all the trumpeting I hear from the coalition parties and their supporters I hear no mention of it.
That forgetting is intentional. It is necessary for the narrative of Stanford’s reforms being successful and necessary, to have been the only option, to take hold. That void allows the arc to move seamlessly from vagueness and failure to specificity and achievement.
The refresh work upsets that hero’s journey. It too brought more clarity to what was to be learned. Its evidence base was broad, deep and inclusive of research done here and overseas. As the refresh progressed we began to see a positive turn in achievement. I wonder what the impact of the refreshed curriculum, the actual Te Mātaiaho, would have had on learners and achievement if it was rolled out?
⚫
“If the Minister surrounds herself with external advisors who believe that Māori knowledge should only appear in New Zealand schooling as a kind of anthropological object of study rather than a knowledge system in its own right, it gives Māori a clear signal. It tells them that decisions about what and how their tamariki and mokopuna are taught are being made by people who do not understand and respect their values, their beliefs, and their cultural practices.” (page 226)
We can do better than this.
A world-class education system is one that is not afraid of helping kids understand what it means to live in their place.
A world-class education system is one that is not afraid of the beauty that exists beyond the textbook.
A world-class education system is one that is not afraid of Māori.
“On 3 November 2025, Minister Stanford introduced Amendment Paper 428, proposing the removal of school boards’ explicit Tiriti obligation, along with other amendments agreed to by Cabinet in October 2025. The wording used in the Amendment Paper was different to what was proposed by Minister Stanford and agreed to by the Cabinet Social Outcomes Committee and Cabinet. The obligation relating to cultural diversity omitted the reference to ‘te ao Māori’. It instead obliged the board to ensure it ‘takes reasonable steps to ensure that the policies and practices for the school reflect New Zealand’s cultural diversity’. We do not have evidence explaining when or why this change was made.” (Page 53)
By introducing these amendments at the Committee of the Whole House stage of the legislative process, Stanford was able to avoid any consultative and select committee scrutiny. These are essential parts of the democratic process.
Even more alarming is the opaqueness around when or why the changes were made. However, the Tribunal inquiry was able to trace an evidential path that suggests the intent for this was present in Stanford’s thinking from as early as May 2024.
What this amounts to is government that operates according to the unilateral assertion of executive power. The potential for this has always been present in our system, and is something that has been abused by previous governments seeking to impose radical change that has no electoral mandate.
On Saturday we face a choice. If the coalition are able to form another government we can expect more of this form of lawmaking. It is a form that never serves the interests of anyone but the powerful and connected, and that circle never expands. If history is any guide, it is likely to contract.
Your vote should reflect the fact you are likely to be outside that circle.
⚫
“Despite forgoing a Regulatory Impact Statement, from what we have seen the Minister sought no official advice on the specific changes. Indeed, the Minister’s Cabinet paper contained no information about, or analysis of, the potential risks to ākonga Māori or other Māori interests posed by the reforms. While the Minister noted the Crown would retain its ‘Treaty responsibilities in respect of schools’ in section 4(d) and 32 of the Act, she made no mention of what impact her section 127 changes might have on the Crown’s ability to fulfil its treaty obligations at the schooling level.” (page 72)
Stanford has claimed that the proper place for the Crown’s treaty obligations to be held is with her, as Minister, not boards. But there is no evidence of her getting any advice as to the practical implications of that claim. Instead, she has reduced those obligations to academic achievement.
No one is disputing that achievement is important, and a key pursuit of schooling. But it is not the sole domain of the Crown’s obligations to Māori, or indeed all students. The day-to-day experience of school, of learning, of the relationships learners have, the contexts in in which learning is situated, the opportunities and support learners get – these are all treaty obligations. There is no way Stanford can have any practical impact on those aspects for all the schools in this country.
That is why 127(1)(d) delegated responsibility for these obligations to boards.
Stanford has made a decision without advice or analysis pertaining to that decision. This is not democratic governance, it is the exercise of executive power.
⚫
“When introduced to the House, Minister Stanford’s Amendment Paper was accompanied by a supplementary disclosure statement, produced by the Ministry of Education and dated 24 October 2025. As noted in section 2.4.1, the statement identified a number of risks to both Māori interests and the Crown’s discharge of its treaty obligations posed by the reforms. For example, the statement advised that removing the explicit obligation for school boards to give effect to te Tiriti ‘could reduce the Crown’s ability to support Māori educational success in accordance with its obligations under article three of Te Tiriti / the Treaty’.” (page 74)
The Tribunal notes that this statement was prepared by the Ministry of Education after Cabinet made the decision to remove section 127(1)(d).
Stanford has claimed she has done more for Māori than any other Minister of Education. It is hard to reconcile that claim with this kind of advice, which the keen-eyed among you will note references article three. This article is generally considered to have little difference across the English and Māori versions. It grants “royal protection” and “all the Rights and Privileges of British Subjects”.
So, we must ask ourselves what protection, rights and privileges Māori learners are entitled to in school to meet that high bar of “all”.
Despite the belief of some influential advisers to the Minister that sociocultural factors are “not terribly useful in the classroom in a practical sense", what students experience at school is not just a technical question answered by The Science of Learning (TM). They are immersed in the sociocultural fabric of the school, both in and out of the classroom, and that fabric is where learners sense whether they belong there, or not. To belong is to be accepted for who you are and have the opportunity and support to pursue and find success in that.
Students who experience belonging tend to achieve well. Boards are best placed to weave a sociocultural fabric which enables that.
By relieving boards of the obligations set out in 127(1)(d) , Stanford is not just breaching the treaty, she is putting the achievement of Māori at risk.
⚫
“If the Crown has chosen school boards as the entity through which to govern schools, then it must ensure that governance occurs in a treaty-consistent manner. To argue otherwise is to imply the everyday experience of ākonga Māori in the State education system is irrelevant to the treaty consistency of the Crown’s schooling system as a whole.” (page 79)
State schools are the means through which the Crown provides education, and as such they are an instrument of the Crown.
Around 97% of Māori students attend such schools and that makes them treaty partnership sites.
There is no way the Minister can discharge the Crown’s obligations effectively for all schools in the country. Every context is different. That is why the governance entity most suited to the discharge of that obligation is the one closest to the community: school boards.
This required an approach to governance that emphasised the importance of relationships and critical thinking – essential to turn what was learned through relationships into policy and resourcing.
However, the removal of section 127(1)(d) means boards can assume the centralisation and concentration of that obligation in the Minister’s office is sufficient. In the current climate, that means a determined board focus on achievement and attendance.
Quantitative data, systems thinking and compliance are privileged in governance under this model.
It is very easy to lose sight of people and their experience when these are the primary focus.
Given a mantra underpinning these reforms has been to ensure the things that are essential are not left to chance, this is an ironic turn that has already done harm.
⚫
“In a July 2025 interview recorded before the release of the Ministerial Advisory Group’s report, the Minister was asked about whether school boards ought to have a statutory treaty obligation. While not confirming what changes would occur, the Minister confirmed ‘[t]here will be changes’ and that there were ‘some legislative vehicles that are coming up that I will be using’. Pressed on whether ‘all this treaty stuff ’ ought to be removed from education entirely, the Minister replied : ‘In one go. Not four or five or six times according to someone else’s timetable’. Later the Minister added that she would ‘deal with the Treaty in one go, carefully and systematically’.” (page 82)
That interview was on The Platform. The MAG report was the one done by the group appointed by Goldsmith looking into treaty references across a number of pieces of legislation. The “legislative vehicle” was using the committee of the whole to introduce a last-minute amendment paper that removed section 127(1)(d), this avoiding any scrutiny of that decision.
There is a larger political project going on here. It is a project that seeks to once and for all secure settler dominance and security. Having Te Tiriti so prominent in governance thinking in every school was a challenge to that project.
⚫
“section 4(d) provides that a purpose of the Act ‘is to establish and regulate an education system that . . . honours Te Tiriti o Waitangi and supports Māori–Crown relationships’. Section 32(h), in turn, similarly refers to ‘honouring Te Tiriti o Waitangi and supporting Māori–Crown relationships that make a difference to learning’ in the context of the schooling system. ‘Honour’ is a comparatively strong treaty standard, one that reflects a serious statutory expectation that the Crown’s treaty obligations will be upheld in the context of education.” (page 84-85)
These are purpose provisions, there to shape how other sections in the Act are interpreted, including sections 90 and 127. Their presence is what should give all educators hope.
If a board is to take the statutory instruction to honour Te Tiriti seriously, they must do more than comply with the orders coming from one side of that relationship.
And this raises a couple of interesting questions: is a board that fails to engage seriously with iwi acting in contravention of the Act? If it does, what does that expose them to?
The Minister has repeatedly defined the Crown meeting its obligations in education in terms of raising Māori achievement. I don’t think anyone would argue against that. But this is a constrained definition and, as the Tribunal has written, there are more aspects to consider. The curriculum changes, and the failure to include Māori perspectives and research in the curriculum’s design, compound the danger of those other aspects being crowded out and/or made invisible.
The Minister wants us to believe that the curriculum can carry those obligations in full, and therefore all a school needs to do is implement it. However, the curriculum reflects a particular idea about education, and it is colonial in origin and design. Its unilateral imposition betrays the partnership Te Tiriti requires.
So, a board cannot meet the high standard of honouring Te Tiriti by satisfying itself that the Minister is right. Given the Tribunal’s findings, serious questions need to be asked about whether the curriculum undermines a board’s ability to meet its obligations as set out in the purpose provisions. At the very least, there is an incoherence there. While not something boards can resolve, this is a question larger entities have now open to them to pursue.
This is where the hope is: the purpose statements dictate how the sections should be read and applied. This provides the legislative basis for boards to seek out and make lived what becomes visible when a relationship with iwi is taken seriously, and use that to influence the implementation of the curriculum. Where there is tension, surely honour comes into play?
⚫
“… in light of longstanding educational inequities for ākonga Māori and the vulnerable state of taonga like te reo Māori, the Crown’s treaty obligations are enhanced. In view of this, addressing inequities and actively protecting taonga requires vigorous and proactive action on the part of the Crown. Any increase in uncertainty for school boards’ understanding of their statutory objectives in this context is inconsistent with the expectations placed on the Crown.” (page 87)
Inequity in education is not just located in achievement. It is also found in power. Schools are reminders that the Crown assumed sovereignty and so reflect the values and priorities of Pākehā. This is something we did not confront for a long time. Add this fact to the broader destructive effect of colonisation on Māori and you start to get somewhere in understanding why so many Māori struggled at school.
Section 127(1)(d) was a legislative lever that supported boards to confront that history. It was lever to help schools become sites where the promise of Te Tiriti had space to come alive. The curriculum refresh work done up until mid-2023 would have enabled teachers to carry that into the classroom.
Now both are gone. The Act still references Te Tiriti in its purpose provisions, but those are severely constrained by a curriculum that reasserts the power of the coloniser.
⚫
“The Crown, in accordance with the principle of equity, is obliged to address the longstanding educational inequities experienced by ākonga Māori. In rectifying disparities, the Crown is not merely required to provide ‘the same level and type of education to everyone’, but to ensure the education provided to Māori is that which best suits their needs. The existence of longstanding inequities also heightens the Crown’s partnership obligations and kāwanatanga responsibilities in the context of education reforms.” (page 89-90)
There was a moment in Luxon’s post election speech on Saturday night where he turned to the lyrical imaginary, and spoke of flying over this land at night and seeing a light here, a light there – houses scattered amidst the darkness – and how in each he thought of the endeavour that lived, the desire to make something of this place and get ahead; and then he drew an equivalence between the settlers who came from Europe with a dream and Māori who voyaged here to settle, both merging into one, I am sure, in his mind and becoming New Zealanders, inhabiting houses sparkling in the dark.
This is an imaginary that is essential for the coloniser for it erases difference and depends on unseeing and darkness for its logic to hold.
It is an imaginary that subsumes all, in favour of the dreams and desires of the coloniser. In Luxon’s vision I am sure he saw hard-working farmers in nice houses working the land and being rewarded for it; a land full of paddocks and milked cows and sheep; communities gathering to trade stock and celebrate. But there is plenty I bet he didn’t see: polluted rivers; abused animals; desecrated fields; felled forests; employee exploitation; land alienation; poverty …
Of course, those in charge of realising the colonial imperative do not need to see these things. All they need to see is the imaginary so they can get the settings set just right for progress, prosperity and profit. Nothing else matters. There is one way, for one people, in this new land.
Stanford has developed a curriculum that works just as Luxon’s imaginary does.
⚫
“In her October 2025 Cabinet paper, Minister Stanford explained this amendment ‘reflects the need to elevate Māori educational achievement and success’. However, no explanation was provided by the Minister as to how the amendment, which weakens the expectation on school boards and removes explicit references to the treaty, would ‘elevate’ Māori educational achievement. What is more likely, therefore, is that Minister Stanford meant that ākonga Māori educational achievement had been ‘elevated’ in the sense that it was now to be listed first in the provision, rather than that this specific reform was directed to substantively address that issue.” (page 90-91)
Remember that the Tribunal in its previous reports in this inquiry found the evidence base for the curriculum reforms was narrow and thin, calling it a “self-referencing feedback loop”. Remember that Stanford has said multiple times that all brains learn the same. Remember she is surrounded by individuals who dismiss sociocultural theories as being of little practical use, question the effectiveness of culturally responsive teaching, and view constructivist pedagogies as theories that have ruined education. And remember, one of the most influential advisors in this process has said she hoped the curriculum reforms could be the circuit breaker that ends decolonisation’s success.
If decolonisation’s success ends, colonisation re-emerges as the dominant force in this land. There is nowhere on earth where it has raised the prospects of indigenous peoples and made them the equals of the colonisers. This is the point.
Stanford’s case for curriculum reform has been built on a narrative of failure. Parents have been primed to fear the failure of their own children. Yet, the parents she mostly targets are the parents who generally have the least to fear.
Stanford knows this narrative only works when failure is a permanent feature of the system. The neoliberal reforms of the 1980s and 1990s did this with employment: fear of joining the growing numbers of unemployed helped to open the political space for the dismantling of workers’ rights.
We have a deep evidence base for the kinds of education approaches that improve the outcomes of Māori and Pacific kids. We were beginning to act on it. Stanford’s reforms have ignored that evidence because it is a threat – it both raises achievement, thus undermining the fear narrative, and promotes cultural and language diversity, therefore strengthening different cultural power bases. Imagine if that wasn’t dismantled.